Off-Broadway’s ‘Romy & Michele’ Musical Disappoints Critics, Audience

URGENT UPDATE: The Off-Broadway musical adaptation of ‘Romy and Michele’ has opened at Stage 42, but reviews are pouring in with overwhelmingly negative feedback. Critics are declaring it “as painful as a real high school reunion,” leaving audiences questioning whether to shell out $100 for tickets.

The show, which features popular actresses Laura Bell Bundy and Kara Lindsay, is a musical rendition of the cult classic film from 1997. However, early reports suggest it fails to capture the charm and humor that made the original a fan favorite. Critics have noted that the production lacks the “anarchic silliness” that defined the film, leading many to feel disappointed.

The musical first premiered in Seattle in 2017 and has since traveled to New York. Despite the star power of Bundy and Lindsay, reviews indicate that the chemistry and comedic timing reminiscent of Mira Sorvino and Lisa Kudrow are sorely missing. Critics argue that the duo struggles to deliver laughs, undermined by a script that closely follows the film’s plot without offering fresh material.

Musical numbers composed by Gwendolyn Sanford and Brandon Jay have also drawn criticism for lacking the vibrant 1990s flair that audiences might expect. Instead, the score is described as generic Broadway pop, failing to resonate emotionally with the audience.

The production, directed by Kristin Hanggi, has been characterized as chaotic and visually cluttered. Critics lament that the set design does not support the comedic potential of the story, relying on “too on-the-nose” visual gags that fall flat.

Audience reactions during previews have been lukewarm, with many expressing their desire for a more engaging and fun experience. “What went wrong here?” one critic asks, emphasizing that the show does not build the empathy needed for a successful musical.

As the opening night approaches, theatergoers are left to decide whether to attend this lackluster reunion or skip it altogether. The future of ‘Romy & Michele The Musical’ hangs in the balance, with many hoping for a turnaround before its official run concludes.

For those curious about this adaptation, the show is currently performing at Stage 42 in New York City, with tickets available for purchase online. However, given the critical responses, potential attendees may want to think twice before making a commitment.

Stay tuned for further updates as this story develops.