MLB Predictions Graded: Teams Face Mixed Outcomes for 2025

UPDATE: Major League Baseball (MLB) teams are reflecting on their bold season predictions as the 2025 season concludes, revealing a mix of triumphs and disappointments. Analysts are now grading these predictions, and the results will have fans buzzing across social media!

For the Pittsburgh Pirates, the forecasted success of rookie Paul Skenes has come to fruition. Skenes not only clinched the Cy Young Award but also achieved the best season for a Pirates starter since 1920, boasting a remarkable 1.97 ERA and a 7.7 WAR. Analysts awarded this prediction an A+ grade, with hopes for an even better 2026.

In the American League, the Seattle Mariners celebrated a stellar season from Bryan Woo, who finished with a 15-7 record and a 2.94 ERA. Woo’s exceptional performance earned him another A+ grade. The Mariners will rely on him and a healthier rotation next year as they look to break their World Series drought.

However, not all teams fared equally well. The New York Yankees shockingly exceeded predictions by clinching 94 wins instead of the anticipated 80-82, largely due to impressive performances from Aaron Judge and newcomers. This unexpected success earned the Yankees an F grade, as analysts had forecasted a losing season.

The Boston Red Sox saw mixed results with their outfield trio. While Ceddanne Rafaela and Wilyer Abreu both secured Gold Gloves, Jarren Duran fell short, earning a B+ grade for this bold prediction. The Red Sox are expected to rotate their outfielders in 2026, possibly leading to offseason trades.

Meanwhile, the Cleveland Guardians and Detroit Tigers also received high marks. Gavin Williams led the Guardians with a 3.06 ERA and 3.8 WAR, warranting an A+ grade. The Tigers’ Riley Greene similarly shone, hitting 36 home runs and making the All-Star Game, earning a solid A grade despite a drop in overall performance metrics.

On the other hand, the Cincinnati Reds faced disappointment as Elly De La Cruz fell short of expectations, hitting only 22 home runs and stealing 37 bases. This regression earned a D grade, raising concerns for the team’s future.

As analysts grade these predictions, the focus now shifts to the offseason and what teams can do to improve their standings moving forward. With the 2026 season approaching, teams are strategizing on trades, free agency, and player development to enhance their rosters.

Fans are urged to stay tuned for further updates as teams finalize their plans, and emotions run high in anticipation of next year’s season!