Meghan Markle’s Formal Introduction Sparks Criticism from PR Expert

Meghan Markle has come under scrutiny following her recent interview with *Harper’s Bazaar*, where a small detail has ignited a larger discussion about her public image. In the magazine’s December 2025 issue, Markle was introduced by a staff member as “Meghan, Duchess of Sussex” during a conversation with journalist Kaitlyn Greenidge. This moment, which took place in a private setting, has led to mixed reactions from the public and royal observers alike.

Critics, including public relations expert Renae Smith, founder and director of The Atticism, have deemed the introduction as “cringe-worthy” and detrimental to Markle’s reputation. Smith pointed out that the announcement seemed overly formal and unnecessary, particularly given the private nature of the interaction. She remarked, “Being formally announced as ‘Meghan, Duchess of Sussex’ in a private home is so painfully performative.”

Smith criticized the planning behind such an introduction, indicating that such formalities do not happen spontaneously. “That would have been planned,” she explained, suggesting that Markle either consented to the announcement or requested it herself. According to Smith, either scenario reflects poorly on Markle’s public persona, stating, “It is tone deaf.”

The backlash stems not from the title of Duchess itself, but from the implications of using it in a casual setting. Many see the moment as indicative of Markle’s ongoing struggles with public perception. Smith articulated concerns that such actions could harm Markle’s brand, calling it “messy” and indicating that she requires a more adept brand strategist who can guide her decisions.

While some fans defended Markle, asserting that she should embrace her title, others echoed Smith’s sentiments, emphasizing that the formal introduction came off as awkward. This incident has revived discussions about how Markle navigates her identity as a member of the royal family while also seeking to establish her own brand.

As public discourse continues to unfold, the implications of Markle’s actions highlight the challenges faced by public figures in balancing personal authenticity with public expectation. The incident serves as a reminder of the intricacies of image management in today’s media landscape, particularly for those who occupy a dual role as both celebrities and former royals.